Hi Paul, -20°F is way colder than a freezer needs to be. You want about 0°F there, so yours is running a lot harder than it should. The good news is that a too-cold freezer is often an easier fix than a warm one.
Your Kenmore 596 is made by Whirlpool. On this kind of refrigerator there’s one cooling system, and the compressor keeps running until both sides are happy. So when the freezer gets super cold, it usually means the compressor isn’t shutting off, often because something is making the fridge side ask for more cold.
What I’d check, in this order
- The settings. Make sure nobody turned the freezer to the coldest setting. A middle setting is right for most homes.
- Door seals. Close the door on a dollar bill in a few places. If it slides out easily, warm air is leaking in and the compressor runs nonstop. Also check that nothing is keeping a door from closing all the way.
- Condenser coils. At 12+ years they’re probably dusty. Unplug it, take off the bottom front grille and vacuum the coils. Dirty coils make the compressor run longer.
- Does it ever stop? Listen for the compressor cycling off. If it runs nonstop for hours even with good seals and clean coils, the cause is usually the temperature control (the control board or a cold control on older models) or a sensor reading wrong.
Your fridge side at 36°F is fine, so food is safe for now. If the seals and coils check out and it still runs nonstop, the control is the next thing to look at, and that’s usually a reasonable repair even on an older unit. Let me know what you find and I’ll help with the next step.

