Hi Dominic,
Good news first: a fridge that still holds temperature and only makes a click when the compressor kicks on is usually not in trouble. Here’s how I’d sort out whether it’s normal or an early warning.
What that click usually is
On a fridge like yours, the compressor is started by a small start relay and overload that plug onto the side of the compressor, down behind the back access panel. When the thermostat calls for cooling, that relay snaps closed and you hear a single solid click, then the compressor hums. You’ll often hear a softer click again when it shuts off. That’s completely normal.
Other normal clicks on older fridges: the cold control (thermostat) clicking on and off, and the defrost timer switching in and out of defrost a few times a day. Since your ice maker is off and the water isn’t hooked up, the water valve isn’t the source. You did the right thing leaving the arm up in the off position.
When the click means trouble
Listen for this pattern: click, a few seconds of hum or nothing, then another click, repeating every few minutes while the compressor never really gets going. That’s the overload tripping because the compressor can’t start, and it’s usually a worn start relay. Left alone, it usually ends with a fridge that won’t cool.
If you want to check it yourself:
- Unplug the fridge, pull it out and take off the thin cardboard or metal panel at the bottom back.
- Look at the relay on the side of the compressor. Signs of burning, melted plastic or a rattle when you gently shake it (once it’s off the compressor) mean it’s due for replacement.
- While you’re back there, vacuum the condenser coils and check the condenser fan spins freely. A dirty coil makes the compressor work harder to start.
A start relay is an inexpensive part, roughly $20–60, and a simple plug-on swap. If a new relay doesn’t stop the repeat clicking, the compressor itself is the next suspect, and that’s sealed-system work for a technician only. I’ve listed the part below so you can check price and availability right there.
About the age
I can’t reliably date it from that serial number alone. Look for a manufacture date on the data tag inside the fresh-food section, usually on a side wall or under the crisper drawers, or on a sticker on the back. Your 12–15 year guess sounds right for that style. If it ever does need a compressor, our repair-or-replace tool will help you decide whether it’s worth it.
If the clicking changes or starts repeating, send a follow-up and tell me what pattern you hear. I’m happy to help you narrow it down.

