Hi Larry,
Water running down the top of a softener every time it recharges is a pain, and good call unplugging it. The leak happening only during regeneration is a helpful clue: that’s when the control valve moves to backwash and brine positions and pushes water out the drain line under pressure. So the leak is almost always at the valve head on top, not the tank itself.
What I’d check first
- Drain line. Follow the small drain hose from the valve to the floor drain or standpipe. A kink, a clog, or a hose end that’s sitting under water makes pressure back up, and water comes out around the valve and fittings. Clear it and make sure it isn’t raised more than a few feet.
- Drain fitting. Where the drain hose connects to the valve there’s a small elbow with a flow restrictor inside. If it’s packed with resin beads or scale, it causes exactly this kind of overflow. Take it off and rinse it out.
- Find the exact spot. Put the softener in bypass, remove the top cover, plug it back in and start a manual recharge. Watch with a flashlight and dry paper towels to see whether water comes from the drain fitting, the bypass valve O-rings, a fitting on the tank collar, or the valve body itself.
- Brine tank. Check that the brine tank isn’t overfilling and spilling over its top during the refill step.
Likely parts
If water is seeping from the valve body or around the motor/rotor area during the cycle, the internal rotor seals are worn. That’s a common fix on older softeners and the kits are usually inexpensive (roughly $20–$60). If it’s coming from the bypass valve or inlet/outlet connections, a set of O-rings usually takes care of it. I’ve listed both below. You can check price and availability right there.
Unplug the unit and put it in bypass (or shut the water off) before taking anything apart. If you see a crack in the valve housing itself, that means replacing the valve, and on an older unit it’s worth comparing that cost against a new softener. Our repair or replace tool can help.
Once you’ve watched a regeneration and know where it’s coming from, send a follow-up with a photo of the leak spot and the valve. I’ll help you narrow it down.

