Hi Gabrielle, you’ve actually already done the most useful test there is. If clearing it out and defrosting the whole fridge brings the cold back for a while, and then it slowly warms up again, that’s a classic sign that the automatic defrost isn’t working.
Why the fridge warms up but the freezer doesn’t
On your Whirlpool French door, all the cold air is made on one cooling coil behind the freezer’s back panel and then blown up a duct into the fridge. Normally a heater melts the frost off that coil a few times a day. When it stops, frost builds up until it blocks the airflow. The freezer, sitting right next to the coil, still stays cold, but the fridge at the end of the duct gets starved first, which is exactly what you’re seeing.
What usually fails
- The defrost heater (Whirlpool calls it the evaporator heater). This is the most common one, and it’s a fairly inexpensive part.
- The defrost thermostat or sensor that tells the heater when to come on.
- Less often, the main control board that runs the defrost.
How to check it
Unplug the fridge, move the frozen food to a cooler, and remove the back panel inside the freezer. If the coil is caked in frost, that confirms it. With a multimeter, the heater should show continuity (a reading, not “open”). If it’s open, the heater is bad. If it reads fine, the thermostat or control is next.
Repair or replace?
Your fridge is over 12 years old, but this is one of the repairs I’d still do on a fridge that age: the part is cheap and the job takes an afternoon for a handy person. If it turns out to need the control board or anything in the sealed system, that’s when I’d look at a new fridge.
I’ve listed the heater for your exact model below. If the coil isn’t frosted when you open it up, send a follow-up and tell me what you see, because then we’re looking at something else.

