Hi G,
Two burners stuck on full blast make simmering impossible. On your Whirlpool WFE510S0AS0 (a coil-element range) this is almost always a burner switch problem, and it’s an affordable fix.
First, make sure it’s really stuck on high
On a coil range the burner switch (an “infinite switch”) doesn’t dim the element. At lower settings it turns it fully on, then off, then on again, so a red coil on Medium is normal as long as it goes dark now and then.
Quick test: set a problem burner to LO and watch it for 3–4 minutes. If it fades out now and then, the switch is working. If it stays bright red the whole time, the switch is stuck.
Why it happens and what to replace
The contacts inside these switches click open and closed all day. After 12+ years they can pit and weld shut, sending full power no matter where the knob is, and two wearing out around the same time is common. The coils rarely cause this. To rule them out, swap a problem coil into a good burner spot. If it works normally there, the switch is the problem.
To replace a switch:
- Turn off the range’s breaker (or unplug it) before you touch anything. These switches run on 240 volts.
- Pull the knob off, then remove the screws on the back of the control panel (backguard) so you can tip it forward or lift it off.
- Photograph the wiring, then move the wires one at a time to the new switch.
- Look for melted or darkened wire ends. If you find any, repair them too, or the new switch won’t last.
On your model, both rear burners use the same switch, and the right front and left front each have their own. I’ve listed the exact parts for your model below, so you can check price and availability right there. If it’s the left front burner, the part for it is W10434452. A switch is roughly $25–$60, so a repair makes far more sense than replacing a range that otherwise works fine. There’s a similar case in this Whirlpool range with a burner stuck on high.
If you get stuck
If a new switch doesn’t fix it, or you find burned wiring you aren’t comfortable fixing, tell me which two burners are affected and what you found, and I’ll help you narrow it down. Just send a follow-up anytime.
Good luck, and happy cooking!


