Hi Cynthia,
Brownies fine in the afternoon, pizza underdone that evening: that sudden change is actually a helpful clue. Ovens don't usually drift slowly out of whack; something stopped working, and on a Frigidaire electric range the bake element is the first thing I'd look at.
1. Check the bake element
When you preheat, the oven uses both the bake element (bottom) and the broil element (top). If the bake element fails, the broil element can still warm things up partway, so the oven gets warm but can't reach or hold 400°F. Try this:
- Set Bake to 350°F and wait 3-4 minutes. If the element on the oven floor is visible, it should glow red. If your oven has a smooth floor (a hidden element), feel for heat coming up from the bottom, or try Broil and compare.
- Turn the oven off and let it cool, then look at the element closely. A burned spot, blister, or break means it's bad.
Always turn off the breaker before removing an element. It's held by two screws at the back wall and is an easy swap for most people.
2. If the element looks fine: the temperature sensor
The thin probe sticking out of the upper back wall tells the control how hot it is. If it's reading wrong, the oven shuts off the heat too early. With the breaker off, a technician (or a handy homeowner with a meter) can check it: on Frigidaire ovens it should read about 1,100 ohms at room temperature.
Resetting the clock was a good idea, but this usually isn't a control problem, so I wouldn't buy a board first. I've listed the bake element and the sensor below as the two likely parts. You can check price and availability right there. There's also a similar case on a Frigidaire-built Kenmore oven.
About its age
Your instinct is right that it's not a 2020 model. To pin it down, open the storage drawer and look for the serial tag on the frame. Frigidaire serials usually start with two letters, then a digit for the year and two digits for the week. Send me that number and I'll read it for you. Either way, an element or a sensor is a very reasonable repair on this range.
Let me know what you find. Send a follow-up and I'll help with the next step. Hope you get back to perfect pizza soon!

