Hi Krys, good question, and usually it isn’t an expensive fix. When you lower the shut-off arm, the ice maker starts a cycle: it warms the tray slightly to release the cubes, sweeps them into the bin and refills. If the water in the tray never froze, that cycle pushes out water instead of ice. So the real question is why it isn’t freezing.
1. Check the freezer temperature first
Put a thermometer in a glass of water in the freezer overnight. It should read around 0°F. If it’s warmer:
- Make sure the vents inside the freezer aren’t blocked by food or frost.
- Look for frost building up on the back wall, which points to a defrost problem.
- Check that the fan behind the back panel runs (you’ll hear it when the door is shut and the fridge is cooling).
- Pull the fridge out and vacuum the coils underneath or at the back.
If the freezer is too warm, the ice maker is just the first thing to show it, and food in the freezer will be the next.
2. If the freezer is cold but you still get water
Then the ice maker itself is cycling too early. It has a small built-in thermostat that waits until the tray is frozen before it harvests. When that fails, it dumps the tray while the water is still liquid. On these Whirlpools the ice maker is replaced as one unit, and it’s usually a simple swap: a couple of screws and one plug.
3. Too much water
If the tray is overflowing even when it does freeze, the water valve is letting in too much. That’s less common, but worth noting if you see ice spilled over the edges of the tray.
Start with the thermometer, because it tells you which way to go. I’ve listed the ice maker for your model below in case the freezer checks out fine. Send a follow-up with the temperature you get and I’ll help with the next step.

